Nick's Picks 175

A curated blend of comic book speculation and trivia compiled by the owner of Key Collector Comics.

DC Oct 2025

Absolute Evil #1

Low
$1
Mid
$3
High
$12
View on eBay
Introduction of Joker in full (human form) - appearing in multiple panels but teaser art of a future arc shows a more monstrous version of the character (cameos in multiple issues)
Introduction of Absolute Green Arrow
Introduction of Absolute Hawkman
Introduction of Lex Luthor in the Absolute Universe
Introduction of the Absolute Justice League: Ra’s al Ghul, Veronica Cale, Elenore Thawne, Hector Hammond, Joker, Lex Luthor

✅ This issue is still flying under the radar, similar to DC All-In #1, which introduced the Absolute Trinity

Not only does it introduce (and kill) Oliver Queen who may or may not be the figure behind the spectacularly designed mask of Absolute Green Arrow, but it also presents a dramatically different version of Lex Luthor, whose fallout from his family’s massacre is on the precipice of being explored in Absolute Superman

Bonus: Absolute Hawkman, depicted as a wraithlike mercenary, could flourish in future stories

Dark Horse Comics Jul 2023

Star Wars Hyperspace Stories #6

Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$10
View on eBay
1st appearance of Rotta the Hutt, son of Jabba
[December 2024 - Jeremy Allen White (The Bear) will voice Rotta the Hutt in the Mandalorian and Grogu movie]

✅ Just a reminder, a fairly well-known actor will voice Rotta the Hutt in the Mandalorian movie, who looks like a badass in this image published in Empire Magazine - tap cover and swipe to view image

Foil MBartist
Low
$2
Mid
$8
High
$20
View on eBay

✅ Yo Joe! If your childhood was like mine, you watched the G.I. Joe animated movie from 1987 to the point of memorizing all of Sgt. Slaughter's memorable lines

If that's you, then you'll also recognize the inspiration for this cover as a very nostalgic homage to the opening sequence of the movie

Dark Horse Comics Jul 1986

Dark Horse Presents #1

Low
$2
Mid
$8
High
$25
View on eBay
First comic book published by Dark Horse Comics founded in 1986
1st appearance of Concrete, an average man's journey through life in a stone body
1st appearance of Black Cross, a fearless warrior in a post-apocalyptic world

✅ Notable alone for its significance to comic book history being the first published book by Dark Horse who set the standard for creator-owned properties, this issue also introduced Concrete which cut through the superhero clutter to tell a story that elevated sequential storytelling

Now 20 years after the most recent concrete story, Paul Chadwick will return to the character in the series Stars Over Sand, on-sale June 2026

Low
$8
Mid
$20
High
$75
View on eBay
1st full appearance of She-Ra in a standard US comic
She-Ra previously appeared in mini-comics packaged with toys and other He-Man Universe merchandise and on a variant cover of He-Man and the Masters of the Universe #1 (2013)

✅ While pricey, I could see a post-credit Masters of the Universe scene introducing She-Ra and causing the market to go ballistic

Antarctic Press Mar 2002

Monster Club #2

Variant
Low
$12
Mid
$40
High
$125
View on eBay
Variant cover art by Skottie Young

✅ Here’s an overlooked issue that could be hiding in long boxes and sells for $100+

Remember to check the Dollar Bin Diving category to discover higher-value comics that can still be found out in the wild

Marvel Jul 2025 Vol 2

Magik #7

Variant
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$4
View on eBay

✅ I feel Joe Quinones captured retro style beautifully on this cover

Magik is a top-tier variant character, and her scarcer covers often command a solid resale value on eBay

DC Oct 2008

Looney Tunes #165

Low
$3
Mid
$9
High
$30
View on eBay
Roadrunner vs Speedy Gonzales race
Copies ordered by retailers: 2,661

✅ Superman versus the Flash is great but who wouldn't want to see these two speedsters in a race

DC Apr 2021 Vol 2

Joker, The #2

Low
$1
Mid
$5
High
$15
View on eBay
1st appearance of Vengeance, daughter of Bane
1st team appearance of the Sampson family, inspired by the family from Texas Chainsaw Massacre

✅ Another character that could have a major moment in comics and get promoted to A-List

DC Mar 1977

Shazam #28

Low
$15
Mid
$50
High
$150
View on eBay
2nd appearance of Black Adam in an original story
There was a fanzine published prior to this issue called Alter Ego where Black Adam appears on the cover but the interior is a text article recapping the Marvel Family and Black Adam written by prominent Marvel architect Roy Thomas before his tenure at Marvel began

✅ Leading up to the Dwayne Johnson led Black Adam film, this issue was selling for close to $600 ungraded

Now you can scoop it up for under $200 and with a long future of DC movies and TV, it is likely we'll see him once again

Low
$18
Mid
$60
High
$180
View on eBay
1st full appearance of Darkseid
1st team appearance of The Forever People: Beautiful Dreamer, Mark Moonrider, Serifan, Big Bear, Vykin the Black
First mention of Mother Boxes, sentient supercomputers of vast power and the Anti-Life Equation
1st appearance of Infinity-Man, a protector of The Forever People

✅ New Teen Titans #2 (Deathstroke), Teen Titans #44 (Nightwing), and DC Comics Presents #26 (Cyborg, Raven, Starfire) are all undervalued key issues in my humble opinion (IMHO for the kids), but none is as undervalued as Forever People #1

Darkseid has been the premier relevant threat in the DC Universe for decades, and he shows no sign of slowing down as the universe reels from K.O., with the company continuing the Darkseid saga throughout 2026 and 2027

plus, we could really use a strong onscreen adaptation of the character. The latest 9.8 copy of Forever People #1 sold for $2,000, compared to Thanos’s first appearance published just two years later in Iron Man #55, which fetched $6,800 for a 9.8

Unfortunately, Darkseid’s first full appearance is preceded by a brief TV-screen cameo in Superman’s Pal Jimmy Olsen #134, which sells for $10,000+ for a 9.8, though copies below 9.0 go for a more palatable $350

Low
$1
Mid
$5
High
$15
View on eBay
Introduction of Darkseid's Omega beams, referred to as 'finder beams' capable of destroying life

✅ Here's another fun Key Issue for Darkseid's first use of the Omega Beams

DC Apr 2015 Vol 2

Justice League #40

Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$8
View on eBay
1st cameo appearance of Grail, daughter of Darkseid
⚠ Misconception: cited by some sources as the first appearance of Grail but she is obscured by shadows in the final panel
First full appearance of Grail - Free Comic Book Day 2015: Divergence #1

✅ As the daughter of Darkseid, Grail has yet to become a DC villain worthy of her pedigree, but that could change

Tiny Onion Studios Aug 2020

Razorblades Magazine #1

Low
$3
Mid
$9
High
$30
View on eBay
Preview of Killboy

✅ It seems like every James Tynion property becomes a hit, and soon Killboy, first previewed in this publication, will get his own comic book series, though no release date has been set yet

Marvel Jan 1981

Amazing Spider-Man #212

Low
$4
Mid
$12
High
$40
View on eBay
1st appearance and origin of Hydro-Man

✅ We’re getting a lot of villains in Brand New Day, but the MCU hasn’t properly paid Hydro-Man his dues, and the water elemental in Far From Home doesn’t quite count

Marvel Oct 1966

Uncanny X-Men #27

Low
$30
Mid
$90
High
$300
View on eBay
First meeting of Spider-Man and the X-Men
Mimic joins the X-Men becoming the first member to join the team outside of the original lineup, but departs shortly afterward in X-Men #29

✅ There is considerable speculation that there will be some mutant presence in Brand New Day

however, with so many villains already confirmed, the film could feel overcrowded

It seems more likely that Spider-Man will meet the X-Men (or mutants) at some point later in the MCU, which highlights how undervalued this historic comic remains as a first meeting

Earlier comics featuring Spider-Man alongside the X-Men did not depict the characters interacting in the same scene

In this issue, Spider-Man meets Beast and Iceman, while Professor X telepathically urges them to invite him to join the X-Men

Notably, there are still many ungraded copies available for under $100 on eBay, along with a handful of 7.0–8.5 graded copies listed between $100–$300

Low
$2
Mid
$8
High
$20
View on eBay
Reprint The Maxx #1, The Maxx #21, The Maxx #23 and Hero Comics 2014 plus an art gallery
Copies ordered by retailers: 3,227

✅ While you don’t get a substantial amount of new content from the recently deceased, one-of-a-kind artist Sam Kieth, this compendium is likely difficult to find, with an estimated 3,227 copies ordered by shops, especially when compared to the relatively scarce final issue, which saw around 22,000 copies ordered

Flip Cover
Low
$1
Mid
$5
High
$15
View on eBay
Origin of Wolverine's yellow and blue suit that was first seen in The Incredible Hulk #180

✅ Not to put too fine a point on Sam Kieth’s contribution to comics, but if you were a collector in the ’80s and ’90s, his instantly recognizable style felt like a fresh coat of paint on the hobby, similar to the efforts of McFarlane, Liefeld, Jim Lee, Jae Lee, Silvestri, Turner, Larsen, the list goes on

Beginning with Marvel Comics Presents #85, Sam Kieth and various writers add detail to Wolverine’s backstory, including the origin of his codename and suit, during the most defining era of the A-list mutant’s history

Clicking on the eBay link and making a purchase may result in this site earning a commission from the eBay Partner Network.

No Results Found

Try adjusting the "Variants" search filter above, or disable "Keys Only" to see all issues.

  • Variant Covers ()