Modern Horror

Support Key Collector Comics continued development by utilizing eBay links when making ANY purchase

Clicking on the eBay link and making a purchase may result in this site earning a commission from the eBay Partner Network.

Killadelphia #1

Image ⋅ 2019

View Details ⋅ View Variants (5)

Low

Mid

High

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

The horror of corruption and violence unfolds before a small-town cop who has returned to Philadelphia to bury his murdered father

[April 2020 - optioned by Levantine Films for a TV series]

Key Facts

The horror of corruption and violence unfolds before a small-town cop who has returned to Philadelphia to bury his murdered father

[April 2020 - optioned by Levantine Films for a TV series]

Nightcry #1

Visual Anarchy ⋅ 1994

View Details

Low

Mid

High

$20

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Anthology of horror stories with creators including Brian Pulido, Ed McGuinness, Everette Hartsoe and others

Key Facts

Anthology of horror stories with creators including Brian Pulido, Ed McGuinness, Everette Hartsoe and others

Clean Room #1

Non-Key

DC Vertigo ⋅ 2015

View Details

Low

Mid

High

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

A woman is determined to bring down a self-help guru and immerse herself in the Clean Room where people's worst moments and deepest fears are revealed

Key Facts

A woman is determined to bring down a self-help guru and immerse herself in the Clean Room where people's worst moments and deepest fears are revealed

The Walking Dead #1

Image ⋅ 2003

View Details ⋅ View Variants (156)

Low

$165

Mid

$410

High

$1.2k

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Premiere issue of an ongoing series about survivors of a zombie outbreak from writer Robert Kirkman

Adapted by AMC for cable television

1st appearance of Rick Grimes

1st appearance of Shane Walsh

Print run: 7,266

Key Facts

Premiere issue of an ongoing series about survivors of a zombie outbreak from writer Robert Kirkman

Adapted by AMC for cable television

1st appearance of Rick Grimes

1st appearance of Shane Walsh

Print run: 7,266

Revival #1

Image ⋅ 2012

View Details ⋅ View Variants (11)

Low

Mid

High

$15

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Officer Cypress leads the Revitalized Citizen Arbitration Team charged with killing zombies

[May 2024 - SyFy to adapt Revival for a TV series]

Key Facts

Officer Cypress leads the Revitalized Citizen Arbitration Team charged with killing zombies

[May 2024 - SyFy to adapt Revival for a TV series]

Kill The Minotaur #1

Non-Key

Image ⋅ 2017

View Details

Low

Mid

High

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Based on the classic Greek myth of Theseus navigating the labyrinth while stalked by the half-man half-bull beast, The Minotaur

Key Facts

Based on the classic Greek myth of Theseus navigating the labyrinth while stalked by the half-man half-bull beast, The Minotaur

Black Monday Murders #1

Image ⋅ 2016

View Details ⋅ View Variants (3)

Low

Mid

High

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Synopsis: Schools of magic are actually clandestine banking cartels who control all of society: a secret world where vampire Russian oligarchs, Black popes, enchanted American aristocrats, and hitmen from the International Monetary Fund work together to keep all of us in our proper place.

Key Facts

Synopsis: Schools of magic are actually clandestine banking cartels who control all of society: a secret world where vampire Russian oligarchs, Black popes, enchanted American aristocrats, and hitmen from the International Monetary Fund work together to keep all of us in our proper place.

Long Lost #1

Scout ⋅ 2017

View Details ⋅ View Variants (2)

Low

Mid

High

$15

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Premiere issue of a series about two sisters drawn back to their small hometown to face the disturbing secrets that lead back to their mysterious mother

Key Facts

Premiere issue of a series about two sisters drawn back to their small hometown to face the disturbing secrets that lead back to their mysterious mother

Dark Red #1

Aftershock ⋅ 2019

View Details ⋅ View Variants (26)

Low

Mid

High

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

A series about vampires in America's heartland

Copies ordered by retailers: 8,680

Key Facts

A series about vampires in America's heartland

Copies ordered by retailers: 8,680

Redneck #1

Image ⋅ 2017

View Details ⋅ View Variants (13)

Low

Mid

High

$10

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Horror series about a family of vampires who have reached the end of an era, peacefully coexisting alongside humans

Key Facts

Horror series about a family of vampires who have reached the end of an era, peacefully coexisting alongside humans

Wraith #1

IDW ⋅ 2013

View Details ⋅ View Variants (7)

Low

Mid

High

$15

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Comic book adaptation of Joe Hill's (son of Stephen King) vampire novel 'NOS4A2' which was also adapted for AMC

Key Facts

Comic book adaptation of Joe Hill's (son of Stephen King) vampire novel 'NOS4A2' which was also adapted for AMC

Locke and Key #1

IDW ⋅ 2008

View Details ⋅ View Variants (11)

Low

$15

Mid

$50

High

$150

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Premiere issue of the first story arc "Welcome To Lovecraft" written by Joe Hill, son of Stephen King

Adapted for a Netflix TV series, premiered February 2020

Copies ordered by retailers: 7,560

Key Facts

Premiere issue of the first story arc "Welcome To Lovecraft" written by Joe Hill, son of Stephen King

Adapted for a Netflix TV series, premiered February 2020

Copies ordered by retailers: 7,560

Afterlife with Archie #6

Archie ⋅ 2014

View Details ⋅ View Variants (1)

Low

Mid

High

$12

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Solo story of Sabrina Spellman aka Sabrina the Teenage Witch in this series

Lead-in to Chilling Adventures of Sabrina spin-off series that spawned a popular TV series

Key Facts

Solo story of Sabrina Spellman aka Sabrina the Teenage Witch in this series

Lead-in to Chilling Adventures of Sabrina spin-off series that spawned a popular TV series

Nameless #1

Image ⋅ 2015

View Details ⋅ View Variants (7)

Low

Mid

High

$12

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Six issue limited series by Grant Morrison that melds horror with sci-fi to create a story about an asteroid headed towards Earth and the unexplained circumstances that precede the disaster

Key Facts

Six issue limited series by Grant Morrison that melds horror with sci-fi to create a story about an asteroid headed towards Earth and the unexplained circumstances that precede the disaster

American Vampire #1

DC Vertigo ⋅ 2010

View Details ⋅ View Variants (3)

Low

Mid

High

$12

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

In the Old West, a diabolical vampire named Skinner Sweet is a new breed of vampire who hunts in the daylight as well as by night

Won the 2011 Harvey and Eisner awards for "Best New Series"

Key Facts

In the Old West, a diabolical vampire named Skinner Sweet is a new breed of vampire who hunts in the daylight as well as by night

Won the 2011 Harvey and Eisner awards for "Best New Series"

Key Facts

A helicopter pilot, shot down behind enemy lines, must battle her way to safety against the opposition and a supernatural horror that resides in the mountains

Key Facts

A helicopter pilot, shot down behind enemy lines, must battle her way to safety against the opposition and a supernatural horror that resides in the mountains

Gideon Falls #1

Image ⋅ 2018

View Details ⋅ View Variants (12)

Low

Mid

High

$12

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Two men become intertwined with the horror and mystery of an urban legend called 'The Black Barn' that appears throughout history bringing with it death and madness

[2021- Lemire tweets the first draft script is finished for a TV series with James Wan directing the pilot]

Key Facts

Two men become intertwined with the horror and mystery of an urban legend called 'The Black Barn' that appears throughout history bringing with it death and madness

[2021- Lemire tweets the first draft script is finished for a TV series with James Wan directing the pilot]

Sweet Tooth #1

DC Vertigo ⋅ 2009

View Details

Low

$12

Mid

$40

High

$120

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

A young man with deer-like features journeys to a sanctuary, hunted by those who believe the half-human-animal hybrids are somehow responsible for the plague that has been erasing humanity

Copies ordered by retailers: 18,551

Adapted for a Netflix television series

Key Facts

A young man with deer-like features journeys to a sanctuary, hunted by those who believe the half-human-animal hybrids are somehow responsible for the plague that has been erasing humanity

Copies ordered by retailers: 18,551

Adapted for a Netflix television series

Winnebago Graveyard #1

Non-Key

Image ⋅ 2017

View Details ⋅ View Variants (4)

Low

Mid

High

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Premiere issue of a series that witnesses the horror experienced by a vacationing family stranded in a small town with a sinister secret

Key Facts

Premiere issue of a series that witnesses the horror experienced by a vacationing family stranded in a small town with a sinister secret

Shanghai Red #1

Non-Key

Image ⋅ 2018

View Details ⋅ View Variants (1)

Low

Mid

High

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Premiere issue about a woman kidnapped aboard a ship and held captive for years out on the sea until she violently changed the course of her life in order to return home

Key Facts

Premiere issue about a woman kidnapped aboard a ship and held captive for years out on the sea until she violently changed the course of her life in order to return home

Regression #1

Non-Key

Image ⋅ 2017

View Details ⋅ View Variants (9)

Low

Mid

High

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Premiere issue in a series about a man plagued by horrific visions but the treatment he is prescribed to eliminate them welcomes an even greater terror into his life

Key Facts

Premiere issue in a series about a man plagued by horrific visions but the treatment he is prescribed to eliminate them welcomes an even greater terror into his life

Outcast #1

Image ⋅ 2014

View Details ⋅ View Variants (9)

Low

Mid

High

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Premiere issue of horror series published by Image

Created by Robert Kirkman and Paul Azaceta

Key Facts

Premiere issue of horror series published by Image

Created by Robert Kirkman and Paul Azaceta

Deep Roots #1

Non-Key

Variant ⋅ Vault ⋅ 2018

View Details ⋅ View Variants (1)

Low

Mid

High

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Premiere issue of an ongoing series about an uprising by the oppressed plant-life, held in captivity by the cement beneath humanity's feet

Key Facts

Premiere issue of an ongoing series about an uprising by the oppressed plant-life, held in captivity by the cement beneath humanity's feet

Pestilence #1

Aftershock ⋅ 2017

View Details ⋅ View Variants (7)

Low

Mid

High

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Premiere issue of an ongoing series about the Black Plague revealed to be a zombie outbreak

Preview of Babyteeth

Key Facts

Premiere issue of an ongoing series about the Black Plague revealed to be a zombie outbreak

Preview of Babyteeth

Submerged #1

Non-Key

Vault ⋅ 2018

View Details ⋅ View Variants (4)

Low

Mid

High

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Premiere issue of a horror series about a girl who goes in search for her brother in the subways of New York City after a frantic call portends his life is in danger

Key Facts

Premiere issue of a horror series about a girl who goes in search for her brother in the subways of New York City after a frantic call portends his life is in danger

Hillbilly #1

Albatross Funnybooks ⋅ 2016

View Details ⋅ View Variants (4)

Low

Mid

High

$15

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Series created by Eric Powell

Key Facts

Series created by Eric Powell

Chew #1

Image ⋅ 2009

View Details ⋅ View Variants (7)

Low

$30

Mid

$90

High

$300

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Image series about a detective who discovers clues from food

Key Facts

Image series about a detective who discovers clues from food

Babyteeth #1

Aftershock ⋅ 2017

View Details ⋅ View Variants (25)

Low

Mid

High

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Horror series that examines the effect on a young mother's life after giving birth to the Anti-Christ

Copies ordered by retailers: 26,514

Key Facts

Horror series that examines the effect on a young mother's life after giving birth to the Anti-Christ

Copies ordered by retailers: 26,514

The Sandman #1

DC Vertigo ⋅ 1989

View Details ⋅ View Variants (6)

Low

$15

Mid

$50

High

$150

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

1st appearance of Dream aka Morpheus

1st appearance of Unity Kincaid

1st appearance of Roderick Burgess

1st appearance of Ethel Cripps

Key Facts

1st appearance of Dream aka Morpheus

1st appearance of Unity Kincaid

1st appearance of Roderick Burgess

1st appearance of Ethel Cripps

Hellboy: The Wild Hunt #3

Dark Horse ⋅ 2009

View Details

Low

Mid

High

$15

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

1st full appearance of Nimue the Queen of Blood

Key Facts

1st full appearance of Nimue the Queen of Blood

Monstress #1

Image ⋅ 2015

View Details ⋅ View Variants (7)

Low

Mid

High

$30

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

1st appearance of Maika

Key Facts

1st appearance of Maika

Nailbiter #1

Image ⋅ 2014

View Details ⋅ View Variants (9)

Low

Mid

High

$10

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

A detective searches for his missing colleague and an answer to why the town of Buckaroo, Oregon has produced sixteen serial killers

[October 2019 - optioned by Skybound Galactic/Sony]

Key Facts

A detective searches for his missing colleague and an answer to why the town of Buckaroo, Oregon has produced sixteen serial killers

[October 2019 - optioned by Skybound Galactic/Sony]

Wytches #1

Image ⋅ 2014

View Details ⋅ View Variants (8)

Price Trend

Low

Mid

High

$15

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Horror series that reinvents the witch genre

[February 2023 - Amazon ordered an animated adaptation for a full season / April 2023 - the first season of Wytches will be 8 episodes and a second season has been green lit]

Key Facts

Horror series that reinvents the witch genre

[February 2023 - Amazon ordered an animated adaptation for a full season / April 2023 - the first season of Wytches will be 8 episodes and a second season has been green lit]

Harrow County #1

Dark Horse ⋅ 2015

View Details ⋅ View Variants (3)

Low

Mid

High

$10

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

A young girl learns that she has a mysterious connection with the ghosts and monsters that live in the woods that surround her home

Harrow County is one of the first few properties Dark Horse and Universal Cable plan on producing

Key Facts

A young girl learns that she has a mysterious connection with the ghosts and monsters that live in the woods that surround her home

Harrow County is one of the first few properties Dark Horse and Universal Cable plan on producing

Ice Cream Man #1

Image ⋅ 2018

View Details ⋅ View Variants (5)

Low

$18

Mid

$60

High

$180

Buy it on eBay!

Key Facts

Premiere issue that features one-shot stories disconnected from one another except for the unsettling, paranormal presence of the Ice Cream Man

Copies ordered by retailers: 9,454

[September 2024 - Alfred Gough and Miles Millar (Beetlejuice 2, Wednesday) to produce an adaptation of Ice Cream Man for Sony]

Key Facts

Premiere issue that features one-shot stories disconnected from one another except for the unsettling, paranormal presence of the Ice Cream Man

Copies ordered by retailers: 9,454

[September 2024 - Alfred Gough and Miles Millar (Beetlejuice 2, Wednesday) to produce an adaptation of Ice Cream Man for Sony]

	Publisher	Low	Mid	High
Killadelphia #1	Image	$1	$2	$8
Nightcry #1	Visual Anarchy	$2	$8	$20
Clean Room #1	DC Vertigo	$1	$2	$3
The Walking Dead #1	Image	$165	$410	$1.2k
Revival #1	Image	$1	$5	$15
Kill The Minotaur #1	Image	$1	$2	$3
Black Monday Murders #1	Image	$1	$2	$3
Long Lost #1	Scout	$1	$5	$15
Dark Red #1	Aftershock	$1	$2	$8
Redneck #1	Image	$1	$2	$10
Wraith #1	IDW	$1	$5	$15
Locke and Key #1	IDW	$15	$50	$150
Afterlife with Archie #6	Archie	$1	$2	$12
Nameless #1	Image	$1	$3	$12
American Vampire #1	DC Vertigo	$1	$4	$12
The Whispering Dark #1	Dark Horse	$1	$2	$4
Gideon Falls #1	Image	$1	$3	$12
Sweet Tooth #1	DC Vertigo	$12	$40	$120
Winnebago Graveyard #1	Image	$1	$2	$4
Shanghai Red #1	Image	$1	$2	$4
Regression #1	Image	$1	$2	$3
Outcast #1	Image	$1	$2	$9
Deep Roots #1	Vault	$1	$2	$5
Pestilence #1	Aftershock	$1	$2	$7
Submerged #1	Vault	$1	$2	$4
Hillbilly #1	Albatross Funnybooks	$2	$5	$15
Chew #1	Image	$30	$90	$300
Babyteeth #1	Aftershock	$1	$2	$8
The Sandman #1	DC Vertigo	$15	$50	$150
Hellboy: The Wild Hunt #3	Dark Horse	$1	$5	$15
Monstress #1	Image	$3	$9	$30
Nailbiter #1	Image	$1	$2	$10
Wytches #1	Image	$1	$5	$15
Harrow County #1	Dark Horse	$1	$2	$10
Ice Cream Man #1	Image	$18	$60	$180

Adjust Your Filters To See More Comics!

By default Key Collector searches for Standard Cover Key Issues.

Adjust the "Variants" search filter above for additional content:

Variant Covers ([[totalVariants]])

At Key Collector, our primary focus is on unearthing those rare Standard Cover Key Issues for you. However, the world of comic collectibles is vast and varied. We want to make sure you have the tools to explore it all!