Clicking on the eBay link and making a purchase may result in this site earning a commission from the eBay Partner Network.

Supernatural Freak Machine: A Cal McDonald Mystery #3

IDW • 2005 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Freak Machine: A Cal McDonald Mystery #3
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$4
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #24

Exhibit A Press • 1999 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #24
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #25

Exhibit A Press • 2000 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #25
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #26

Exhibit A Press • 2000 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #26
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #27

Exhibit A Press • 2000 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #27
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #28

Exhibit A Press • 2001 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #28
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #29

Exhibit A Press • 2000 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #29
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #30

Exhibit A Press • 2001 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #30
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #31

Exhibit A Press • 2001 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #31
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #32

Exhibit A Press • 2001 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #32
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #33

Exhibit A Press • 2002 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #33
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #34

Exhibit A Press • 2002 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #34
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #35

Exhibit A Press • 2002 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #35
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #36

Exhibit A Press • 2002 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #36
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #37

Exhibit A Press • 2003 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #37
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #38

Exhibit A Press • 2003 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #38
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #39

Exhibit A Press • 2003 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #39
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #40

Exhibit A Press • 2003 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #40
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #41

Exhibit A Press • 2005 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #41
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$4
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #42

Exhibit A Press • 2005 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #42
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$4
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #43

Exhibit A Press • 2005 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #43
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$4
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #44

Exhibit A Press • 2007 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #44
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$4
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Law #45

Exhibit A Press • 2008 • Vol. 1
View Details View Series
Supernatural Law #45
 
Low
$2
Mid
$8
High
$20
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Crossover appearance of the Toxic Avenger

Supernatural Special: Castiel #1

Dynamite Entertainment • 2026 • Vol. 1
View Details View Series View Variants (5)
Supernatural Special: Castiel #1
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$6
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

1st appearance of Castiel in a comic book

Supernatural Special: Castiel #1

Dynamite Entertainment • 2026 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
1:10
View Details View Series
Supernatural Special: Castiel #1
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$6
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Special: Castiel #1

Dynamite Entertainment • 2026 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
1:15
View Details View Series
Supernatural Special: Castiel #1
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$6
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Special: Castiel #1

Dynamite Entertainment • 2026 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
Variant
View Details View Series
Supernatural Special: Castiel #1
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$6
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Special: Castiel #1

Dynamite Entertainment • 2026 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
Variant
View Details View Series
Supernatural Special: Castiel #1
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$6
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Special: Castiel #1

Dynamite Entertainment • 2026 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
Blank
View Details View Series
Supernatural Special: Castiel #1
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$6
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Thrillers #1

Marvel • 1972 • Vol. 1
View Details View Series
Supernatural Thrillers #1
 
Low
$5
Mid
$18
High
$70
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Adaptation of the 1940 Theodore Sturgeon short story 'It!'

Story is considered the inspiration for Heap, Swamp Thing, Man-Thing and other swamp based characters

Supernatural Thrillers #2

Marvel • 1973 • Vol. 1
View Details View Series
Supernatural Thrillers #2
 
Low
$5
Mid
$15
High
$50
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

1st appearance of the Invisible Man in Marvel comics

Supernatural Thrillers #3

Marvel • 1973 • Vol. 1
View Details View Series
Supernatural Thrillers #3
 
Low
$4
Mid
$12
High
$40
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

1st appearance of James Allison aka Niord, a man who can recall many past lives

Supernatural Thrillers #4

Marvel • 1973 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Thrillers #4
 
Low
$5
Mid
$12
High
$40
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Thrillers #5

Marvel • 1973 • Vol. 1
View Details View Series
Supernatural Thrillers #5
 
Low
$15
Mid
$50
High
$150
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

1st appearance of the Living Mummy

Supernatural Thrillers #6

Marvel • 1973 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Thrillers #6
 
Low
$5
Mid
$18
High
$55
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Thrillers #7

Marvel • 1974 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Thrillers #7
 
Low
$5
Mid
$15
High
$45
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

2nd appearance of the Living Mummy

Supernatural Thrillers #8

Marvel • 1974 • Vol. 1
View Details View Series
Supernatural Thrillers #8
 
Low
$2
Mid
$8
High
$20
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

1st team appearance of The Elementals: Magnum, Hellfire, Zephyr and Hydron

Supernatural Thrillers #9

Marvel • 1974 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Thrillers #9
 
Low
$5
Mid
$15
High
$45
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Thrillers #10

Marvel • 1974 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Thrillers #10
 
Low
$2
Mid
$5
High
$18
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Thrillers #11

Marvel • 1975 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series View Variants (1)
Supernatural Thrillers #11
 
Low
$5
Mid
$10
High
$35
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Thrillers #11

Marvel • 1975 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
UK Edition
View Details View Series
Supernatural Thrillers #11
 
Low
$2
Mid
$10
High
$30
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Thrillers #12

Marvel • 1975 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Thrillers #12
 
Low
$2
Mid
$8
High
$30
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Thrillers #13

Marvel • 1975 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series View Variants (1)
Supernatural Thrillers #13
 
Low
$5
Mid
$12
High
$40
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Thrillers #13

Marvel • 1975 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
UK Edition
View Details View Series
Supernatural Thrillers #13
 
Low
$2
Mid
$10
High
$30
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Thrillers #14

Marvel • 1975 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural Thrillers #14
 
Low
$5
Mid
$15
High
$50
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Thrillers #15

Marvel • 1975 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series View Variants (1)
Supernatural Thrillers #15
 
Low
$5
Mid
$15
High
$45
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural Thrillers #15

Marvel • 1972 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
UK Edition
View Details View Series
Supernatural Thrillers #15
 
Low
$2
Mid
$10
High
$30
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural: Beginning's End #1

WildStorm • 2010 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series View Variants (1)
Supernatural: Beginning's End #1
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural: Beginning's End #1

WildStorm • 2010 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
Photo Cover
View Details View Series
Supernatural: Beginning's End #1
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Supernatural: Beginning's End #2

WildStorm • 2010 • Vol. 1
Non-Key
View Details View Series
Supernatural: Beginning's End #2
 
Low
$1
Mid
$2
High
$3
View on

Subscribe to Unlock

View Graded Pricing

Unlock graded pricing and other premium features by subscribing to Key Collector Comics.

Subscribe

Price Guide

Prices are estimates based on recent sales data and may not reflect actual market value. Key Collector Comics does not guarantee the accuracy of any pricing information.

Adjust Your Filters To See More Comics!

By default Key Collector searches for Standard Cover Key Issues.

Adjust the "Variants" and/or "Non-Key Issues" search filters above for additional content:

  • Variant Covers ([[totalVariants]])
  • Non-Key Issues ([[totalNonKeys]])

At Key Collector, our primary focus is on unearthing those rare Standard Cover Key Issues for you. However, the world of comic collectibles is vast and varied. We want to make sure you have the tools to explore it all!